A great Web 3 critic blog
One of the most distinguishing features of "web3" is the sheer level of handwaviness surrounding it. While you can find no end of press releases, Twitter crypto bros, and venture capitalists extolling the virtues of web3, you will have a much harder time finding any definition that's not so full of buzzwords that it becomes meaningless.
Generally speaking, web3 is an umbrella term to refer to the "future of the Internet", which believers say will be decentralized and based on the blockchain. Proponents tend to tout how data won't be controlled by "Big Tech", and how it will be uncensorable and egalitarian. There is, however, no shortage of examples in this timeline of how many "web3" projects are indeed centralized in similar ways to Big Tech, as well as instances where "uncensorable" or "unmodifiable" platforms have removed or modified data.
Skeptics of web3 tend to point out that decentralization was a founding tenet of the Internet and is not something that is only (or best) achieved with the blockchain. They also tend to point out the enormous environmental impacts of blockchain technology (particularly proof-of work blockchains, including Bitcoin and Ethereum). They also often mention that an awful lot of web3 projects sound quite a bit like Ponzi or pyramid schemes, and question the lack of regulation, oversight, and taxation that makes fraud, tax evasion, and other criminal behavior particularly rampant in the space.
Ideas described as web3 tend to incorporate some of the following:
- various cryptocurrencies
- decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs)
- decentralized finance (DeFi)
- non-fungible tokens (NFTs)
- smart contracts
Yeah we are a web3 skeptics as well. web3isgoinggreat is a fantastic blog dedicated to cover this issue.
- Software Engineering